‘Go and Work for an English Company’ – Worker Fired for Being White
A white English man was fired from his job working for “an Asian company” because he was white, an employment tribunal judge has ruled.
31-year-old Colin Sorby had been recruited by a Bradford Management Services, a subsidiary of Mumtaz Foods, which owns restaurants in Bradford and Leeds, on a zero-hours contract, but found that his once plentiful-shifts evaporated after he complained that his Pakistani supervisor, Azheem Akhtar, had said that only South Asians should be working at the company.
“The Tribunal is satisfied that Mr Akhtar called the Claimant to one side in the production area on 16 October 2019 and told the Claimant that this was an Asian company and he should go and work for an English company,” ruled judge T R Smith, rejecting claims that the incident was a misunderstanding resulting from a language barrier after hearing “answering a question in English in a perfectly comprehensible manner” over the course of the proceedings.
“The comment was not trivial or unintended and Mr Akhtar’s intention was to try and persuade the claimant to leave the First Respondent’s employment,” the judge added.
Three weeks after complaining about Akhtar’s comments, Mr Sorby was put “on call” — effectively terminated — by human resources manager Paulo Silva, who cited complaints about Mr Sorby’s performance from the Pakistani supervisor.
“The effect of the comment was that due to the fact the Claimant was English he could not cook Asian food properly. This was a stereotypical assumption that was not predicated on any factual basis,” said the judge, who was clear that there was no evidence of any concern about Sorby’s performance before he complained.
“Again, the context is everything. Mr Akhtar was seeking to justify why the Claimant’s employment should, effectively, be terminated,” the judge added, agreeing that Sorby had been subjected to racial discrimination, harassment, and victimisation, with compensation to be determined at a remedy hearing.